Something went wrong
Please try again
God at the Crossroads of Worldviews
Some error occured while loading the Quick View. Please close the Quick View and try reloading the page.
Couldn't load pickup availability
-
Format:
-
Publication Date: 15 October 2016
-
ISBN: 9780268100568
-
Pages: 300
-
Imprint: University of Notre Dame Press

Debates about the existence of God persist but remain at an impasse between opposing answers. God at the Crossroads of Worldviews reframes the debate from a new perspective, characterizing the way these positions have been defined and defended not as wrong, per se, but rather as odd or awkward. Paul Chung begins with a general survey of the philosophical debate regarding the existence of God, particularly as the first cause, and how this involves a bewildering array of often-incommensurable positions that differ on the meaning of key concepts, criteria of justification, and even on where to start the discussion. According to Chung, these positions are in fact arguments both from and against larger, more comprehensive intellectual positions, which in turn comprise a set of rival "worldviews." Moreover, there is no neutral rationality completely independent of these worldviews and capable of resolving complex intellectual questions, such as that of the existence of God. Building from Alasdair MacIntyre's writings on rival intellectual traditions, Chung proposes that to argue about God, we must first stand at the "crossroads" of the different intellectual journeys of the particular rival worldviews in the debate, and that the "discovery" of such a crossroad itself constitutes an argument about the existence of God. Chung argues that this is what Thomas Aquinas accomplished in his Five Ways, which are often misunderstood as simple "proofs." From such crossroads, the debate may proceed toward a more fruitful exploration of the question of God's existence. Chung sketches out one such crossroad by suggesting ways in which Christianity and scientific naturalism can begin a mutual dialogue from a different direction. God at the Crossroads of Worldviews will be read by philosophers of religion, advanced undergraduate and graduate students, and theologians and general readers interested in the new atheism debates.
“God at the Crossroads of Worldviews affords a substantive and intellectually insightful analysis ranging from diverse yet relevant topics necessary for a new approach.” —Reviews in Religion and Theology
Paul Seungoh Chung is a sessional lecturer at St. Michael's College in the University of Toronto.
Preface
-
To Step Back: Rethinking the Question
-
Where We Stand: The Contemporary Question
-
The Road: Rationality and Worldviews
-
At the Crossroads of Worldviews
-
The Crossroad We Have Passed: The Project of Thomas Aquinas
-
God at the Crossroads: What the Five Ways Do
-
The Fork: The Emergence of Modern Atheism as a Worldview
-
To Set Out: Arguing from the Crossroads to God
Notes
Bibliography
Index